Ways to work with us

MetaBirkins: A Case Study in Trademark Disputes with NFTs

If you read our article Navigating Trademark Issues in the NFT World you’ll know that NFT’s and the rights and obligations to their creation, sale and ownership is a tricky area.

How do you protect a de-centralised asset? 

Can trademark rights be enforced on an NFT?

To answer these questions we are watching closely to see what disputes and legal cases are being reported on in Trademark News and such high-profile case involved MetaBirkins, a collection of NFTs created by digital artist Mason Rothschild. The project quickly became the centre of a heated trademark dispute, highlighting the complexities of trademark protection in the digital age.

The MetaBirkins Trademark Dispute

In 2021, Mason Rothschild launched the MetaBirkins collection, a series of NFTs that reimagined the iconic Hermès Birkin bags with a digital twist. These virtual depictions of luxury handbags gained significant attention for their striking resemblance to the real-life Hermès Birkin bags. However, the project soon landed in legal trouble when Hermès filed a lawsuit against Rothschild, alleging trademark infringement.

Hermès argued that the use of the “Birkin” name and the visual similarity of the MetaBirkins NFTs could mislead consumers into thinking the digital assets were affiliated with or endorsed by the fashion house. Rothschild, on the other hand, defended his work as an artistic expression, sparking debates about the boundaries between artistic freedom and trademark law.

Why This Case Matters

The MetaBirkins case is one of the first high-profile trademark disputes involving NFTs, raising critical questions such as:

Can digital artists use well-known brand names in their creations?

How can brands protect themselves against unauthorised use of their trademarks in digital spaces?

This case is a powerful reminder that as new technologies emerge, so do new challenges for intellectual property protection. For businesses, ensuring comprehensive trademark protection—through UK trademark applications, EU trademark registrations, international trademark registrations tailored to cover digital assets—has never been more critical.

 

Our Thoughts

NFTs, by their nature as digital assets, have global reach, making it essential for brands to think beyond domestic protection. A trademark infringement involving NFTs in one country can quickly impact a brand’s reputation across the world. To safeguard your intellectual property effectively, it’s crucial to consider not only UK trademark applications but also EU trademark registrations and international trademark registrations to secure protection in key markets.

As the digital world continues to grow, taking proactive steps to protect your brand in both the physical and virtual realms is essential. Filing for international trademark registration or expanding your portfolio with an EU trademark registration ensures your intellectual property remains safeguarded against potential misuse in an interconnected, global marketplace.

If you’re unsure how to protect your intellectual property in this rapidly evolving space, consulting with experts who understand the nuances of trademark law across multiple jurisdictions is crucial.

Have a question about protecting your brand in the NFT world?

Contact us today for expert advice on trademark protection, including UK trademark applications, EU trademark registrations, and international trademark registrations.

 

Picture of Jonathan Paton

Jonathan Paton

Founder/Director

Share this post:

Need assistance with trademark registration, monitoring, representation, or other related services? Request a callback from our specialist here. Alternatively you can give us a call on 01618335400 Monday to Friday between 9am and 6pm, we’d love to hear from you.